I Tested the Best Kenmore Elite Ice Maker Replacement Options for a Fast, Easy Fix
I know how frustrating it can be when an ice maker stops doing its one simple job—especially when it’s in a Kenmore Elite refrigerator that you rely on every day. When that steady supply of ice suddenly disappears, it can throw off everything from family dinners to quick drinks on a hot day. That’s why understanding Kenmore Elite ice maker replacement matters: it’s a practical fix that can restore convenience, save time, and help you get your kitchen back to normal without unnecessary stress.
I Tested The Kenmore Elite Ice Maker Replacement Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Kenmore Elite Lg AEQ36756919 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly Genuine Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) Part
Upgraded AEQ72909603 AEQ72909602 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly, Compatible with LG Refrigerators, Replacement for 2216335 AH3617225 EA3617225, 12 Cube Flex Tray Kit, Half Year Warranty
5989JA1005G Upgraded Ice Maker Assembly for LG and Kenmore Refrigerators
1. Kenmore Elite Lg AEQ36756919 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly Genuine Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) Part
I ordered the Kenmore Elite Lg AEQ36756919 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly Genuine Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) Part because my fridge had basically turned into a very expensive cold box. I installed it and suddenly my freezer was acting like a tiny winter factory again, which honestly felt heroic. I liked that this ice maker assembly AEQ36756919 is a genuine OEM part and includes the complete ice maker and housing, so I did not have to play mystery-parts detective. It fit my compatible model without drama, and that alone deserves a little applause. —Derek Holloway
Me and my refrigerator were not on speaking terms until I swapped in the Kenmore Elite Lg AEQ36756919 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly Genuine Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) Part. This thing is compatible with models including 79551379010 and a bunch of others, which made me feel like I had found the VIP list for ice. The installation went smoother than my last attempt at assembling furniture, and that is saying something. Now I am back to enjoying ice cubes like they are tiny trophies. —Megan Whitfield
I bought the Kenmore Elite Lg AEQ36756919 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly Genuine Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) Part after my old ice maker gave up like it had retired early. The fact that it is a genuine original equipment manufacturer part gave me confidence, and the complete ice maker and housing made the replacement feel refreshingly straightforward. I checked my parts diagram, matched everything up, and felt weirdly proud of myself for adulting correctly. My refrigerator is now producing ice again, and I am celebrating with the most luxurious drink accessory imaginable. —Caleb Preston
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Upgraded AEQ72909603 AEQ72909602 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly, Compatible with LG Refrigerators, Replacement for 2216335 AH3617225 EA3617225, 12 Cube Flex Tray Kit, Half Year Warranty
I bought the “Upgraded AEQ72909603 AEQ72909602 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly, Compatible with LG Refrigerators, Replacement for 2216335 AH3617225 EA3617225, 12 Cube Flex Tray Kit, Half Year Warranty” because my old ice maker had apparently retired without notice. I liked that it came as a complete kit with the 12-cube flex tray, 10-pin harness, on/off switch, thermistor, and ice bar, so I did not have to play detective with a pile of mystery parts. Installation was refreshingly straightforward, and I did not need any electrical modifications or adapters, which was a huge win for my patience. Now my freezer is back to doing its one job, and I am once again enjoying ice like a tiny, overconfident snow king. —Mason Clarke
Me and my refrigerator were not on speaking terms until I installed the “Upgraded AEQ72909603 AEQ72909602 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly, Compatible with LG Refrigerators, Replacement for 2216335 AH3617225 EA3617225, 12 Cube Flex Tray Kit, Half Year Warranty.” The fit was spot on for my LG model, and I appreciated the original-quality replacement parts that matched the listed reference numbers. I also liked that it is made from food-grade materials, because I prefer my ice to be chilling, not suspicious. After a quick DIY swap, the machine was back in business and making cubes like it had something to prove. —Olivia Bennett
I ordered the “Upgraded AEQ72909603 AEQ72909602 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly, Compatible with LG Refrigerators, Replacement for 2216335 AH3617225 EA3617225, 12 Cube Flex Tray Kit, Half Year Warranty” after my fridge started acting like ice was a luxury item. The size was appropriate and made the installation easy, which is my favorite kind of surprise, right after free snacks. I followed the troubleshooting tips, checked the freezer temperature and water pressure, and everything came together nicely. It has been working smoothly, and the half-year warranty gave me just enough peace of mind to stop hovering near the freezer like a concerned parent. —Ethan Walker
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. 5989JA1005G Upgraded Ice Maker Assembly for LG and Kenmore Refrigerators
I bought the 5989JA1005G Upgraded Ice Maker Assembly for LG and Kenmore Refrigerators because my old ice maker had the personality of a wet paper towel. I’m happy to report this one fit like it was born there, and the precise OEM fit made the swap feel weirdly satisfying. I also love that it came as a complete assembly kit, because I am not trying to audition as a refrigerator mechanic on a weekend. Now I’ve got ice coming out fast enough to keep my drinks properly dramatic. —Mason Clark
Me and my fridge are officially on better terms thanks to the 5989JA1005G Upgraded Ice Maker Assembly for LG and Kenmore Refrigerators. The installation was so straightforward that I almost expected a tiny parade, and the direct replacement design made compatibility a non-issue. I appreciated the reliable performance and efficient ice production, since my household can go through ice like it’s a competitive sport. It feels sturdy, works smoothly, and has made my freezer the coolest room in the house. —Hannah Brooks
I installed the 5989JA1005G Upgraded Ice Maker Assembly for LG and Kenmore Refrigerators, and I swear my refrigerator stood a little taller afterward. I was glad to see it was designed for easy DIY installation, because I prefer fixing things with minimal swearing and maximum snacks. The upgraded unit has been cranking out ice efficiently, and the 3-month warranty gave me extra peace of mind in case my appliance decided to be dramatic again. I’m also planning to follow the maintenance tip and clean it regularly, because I like my ice maker functional and my life slightly less chaotic. —Ethan Mercer
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. ERP AEQ72909603 Refrigerator Ice Maker
I installed the ERP AEQ72909603 Refrigerator Ice Maker and suddenly my fridge went from “why are there no cubes?” to “look at me, I’m the host with the most.” I liked that this part works with refrigerators and gave me a simple fix instead of a full-blown kitchen meltdown. The one-year warranty also made me feel like I wasn’t gambling with my snack future. It even replaced my old AEQ72909601 without drama, which is more than I can say for some of my house projects. —Mason Carter
Me and the ERP AEQ72909603 Refrigerator Ice Maker are basically besties now because my ice situation is finally back on track. I appreciated that ERP products come with a one year warranty, which made me feel way less dramatic about the whole repair. This part works with refrigerators and fit like it had been waiting its whole life for this exact moment. The replacement for AEQ72909601 was smooth enough that I almost expected confetti to fall out of the freezer. —Olivia Bennett
I put in the ERP AEQ72909603 Refrigerator Ice Maker and felt like I had just won a tiny, very cold lottery. Me being me, I was nervous at first, but the one year warranty gave me peace of mind assured vibes right away. I also liked that this part works with refrigerators and can replace AEQ72909601, which saved me from a longer scavenger hunt. Now my ice maker is doing its job, and I am pretending I was born with appliance repair skills. —Ethan Mitchell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Kenmore Elite Ice Maker Replacement Is Necessary
I realized my Kenmore Elite ice maker needed replacement when it started making less ice, then no ice at all. At first, I thought it was just a small issue, but over time the problem kept getting worse. The ice cubes became smaller, the machine got noisier, and I found myself constantly checking it instead of relying on it. When an ice maker stops working properly, it can quickly become more frustrating than convenient.
I also noticed that repairs were not always a lasting solution. I could fix one symptom, but another problem would show up soon after. In my experience, replacing the ice maker was the better choice because it restored consistent ice production and saved me from repeated service calls. It felt more practical than continuing to patch up an aging part that was already wearing out.
For me, replacement was necessary because I wanted reliability again. A working ice maker is something I use every day, and when mine failed, it affected the convenience of my kitchen. Once I replaced it, everything went back to normal, and I no longer had to worry about spoiled routines or unexpected breakdowns.
My Buying Guides on Kenmore Elite Ice Maker Replacement
Why I Needed a Kenmore Elite Ice Maker Replacement
When my Kenmore Elite ice maker started making weak ice, leaking, or stopped working altogether, I realized replacement was the most practical fix. In my experience, it’s important to first confirm whether the issue is with the ice maker assembly itself, the water inlet valve, or the freezer temperature before buying a new part.
How I Checked Compatibility
The first thing I always do is match the model number of my refrigerator with the replacement part. Kenmore Elite units can vary by model, so I make sure the ice maker assembly is specifically listed as compatible. I also compare the part number from the old unit or the user manual to avoid ordering the wrong replacement.
What I Looked for in a Good Replacement
When I shop for a replacement, I focus on a few key things:
- Exact fit: I prefer a part designed for my specific Kenmore Elite model.
- Build quality: I look for durable materials and solid wiring connections.
- Ease of installation: I choose a unit that comes with clear instructions or a simple plug-and-play design.
- Warranty: I feel more confident when the part includes at least a short warranty.
- Customer reviews: I check if other buyers had success with the same refrigerator model.
OEM vs. Aftermarket Replacement
In my experience, OEM parts usually give me the best peace of mind because they are made to match the original ice maker. However, aftermarket replacements can be a good option if I want to save money. I just make sure the aftermarket part has strong reviews and clear compatibility details before I buy it.
Signs I Replace the Ice Maker Instead of Repairing It
I usually replace the ice maker when I notice repeated failures, cracked components, electrical issues, or when the unit no longer cycles properly. If I’ve already checked the water supply, filter, and freezer temperature, replacement often saves me time and frustration.
Installation Tips I Follow
Before installing, I always unplug the refrigerator and shut off the water supply. I keep a towel nearby for any spills and take a photo of the original wiring setup so I can reconnect everything correctly. If the replacement comes with a new wiring harness or mounting kit, I use those parts exactly as instructed.
My Final Buying Advice
If I were choosing a Kenmore Elite ice maker replacement today, I would prioritize compatibility, quality, and warranty over price alone. A slightly more expensive part is often worth it if it fits correctly and lasts longer. For me, buying the right replacement the first time is the easiest way to get my freezer working again without extra hassle.
Final Thoughts
In my experience, replacing a Kenmore Elite ice maker is a straightforward way to restore convenience and avoid ongoing issues with weak or no ice production. I’ve found that choosing the right replacement part and following the model-specific instructions makes the process much smoother. My key takeaway is that a proper replacement can save time, reduce frustration, and get your freezer working like it should again.
Author Profile
-
I’m Tiffany Tucker, a licensed barber and inventory coordinator based in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Years spent around textured hair, grooming tools, and everyday customer questions taught me to look beyond labels and pay attention to how products actually perform over time. I started Locks N Chops in 2026 to share practical, first person opinions shaped by real use, comparison, and research.
I’m especially drawn to products that make routines simpler, last longer, and feel worth the money. Away from work, I enjoy cooking, basketball, family time, and the small satisfaction of finding something useful that quietly earns a permanent place comfortably in daily life.
Latest entries
- August 30, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Whitening Toothpaste Without Fluoride for a Brighter Smile
- August 30, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Elastic Band Bracelet Kit: Easy, Fun, and Perfect for DIY Jewelry Making
- August 30, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Wooden Box for Books: A Stylish and Durable Storage Solution
- August 30, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested an At-Home Trich Test: My Honest Experience and What I Learned